My family has always loved the Smith however the service was so horrible it put a bad taste in our mouth. We've been coming here for the past 8 years, and it was so unwelcoming.
Our brunch was very good, food was great and we enjoy the atmosphere at the smith. Or server was a bit in the weeds but it was Sunday brunch on Father’s Day. It didn’t impact our overall experience. Will definitely visit again and recommend to friends
Good for Brunch!
It's hard to find a restaurant open at 9 am on Sundays so The Smith is a find. The atmosphere was lively and a line formed quickly. Good food and coffee!
well done rancheros scramble and good coffee, attentive service, not too crowded
Great service, casual vibe and fantastic location. The lobster roll (though a bit overpriced when compared to similar restaurants) was SO good. I would absolutely return to this stylish, subway tiled retreat.
The Smith is always my 'go to' place. I brought in a group of 9 for a great meal and even better conversation. We laughed, networked and just had an overall excellent time. Will always recommend The Smith. I even bought tshirts when I left for family. Thanks for another great experience.
Very lively place for a brunch! Food was very good and choices sufficient. All the tables were full and a crowd waiting out front so they must be doing something right. Nice place for brunch and would go again.
Way way too loud! Never have been in a public place other than a concert that is so loud. Service slow, menu limited...would likely not return.
Food is salty. Service was okay.
A nice restaurant with classic American food. My only complaint would be the extremely high noise level.
Food is always good. The noise level is extremely high. And the restaurant is freezing. But overall a very fun atmosphere with great service—thus I keep on frequenting.
Good food and nice place. Will def come back!
Nice casual spot where you can grab a reservation pretty easily. The interior is spacious and the ambiance is very loud. It is good for big group dinners and brunches; food is solid for NYC pricing.
The food here is always great but this location in particular is VERY noisy. I could barely hear my cousin sitting a foot away from me and we both were screaming to talk to each other because of how loud it was.
the skirt steak is my favorite, with the garlic herb butter, and the salad on the side
Will never eat here again. Food just okay, service good, but noise level was beyond belief at lunch. Absolutely impossible to have a conversation. Noisy restaurants are very common these days, but this was beyond the pale.
Went for brunch and had a delicious meal!! Service was excellent. Can’t wait to go back!!! Soooo Yummy!!
Excellent food choices and quality. Had to work at getting served initially, during and after the meal. Loved the decor.
Food was pretty good but it was so noisy we couldn’t have a conversation. Not a place to go with a hangover ;)
Amazing service! Everything was on point. We had a great time.
Very busy and slow service but overall good experience
Average food and service. No real complaints. But horribly overpriced.
Waiter was rude and completely weird. Other than that we had a great experience , food was amazing! It gets loud bc of the acoustic setup there but nonetheless atmosphere and food made up for it!!
Had a great time, would recommend the Mac and cheese for sure!
Loved it. Abs
Good food, good cocktails, a little loud but overall good experience.
Great food and service as always !!!
Never have a bad meal here. Drove in from CT on a Sunday for this.
If you're looking for great food in a boisterous, energetic environment with great service, this is a fun option for dinner in the city!
The Smith never disappoints! I have been numerous times, and the food is always on par and so delicious, no matter what you select on the menu.
Had a really good server. Seafood excellent as was zucchini flatbread and raspberry rhubarb pie.
Good great, service great, VERY LOUD place
Loved the menu and everything we ordered was executed perfectly. Very bustling noisy place. Not for a quiet dinner or lunch but we loved it and will go again.
Perfect for what it is. Tasty neighborhood dining with a good menu and pleasant service.
Brunch for four. We had a reservation and were seated immediately. Our server was prompt and attentive. The food was great (I think we all had versions of Eggs Benedict- there are multiple versions) and everyone enjoyed their meal. One of our party was lingering over his beer and even though the restaurant was crowded, no one rushed us along. I've eaten at The Smith twice and both times the one drawback was the noise level. I know others have commented on this but it always takes me by surprise how loud this restaurant really is. The first time I ate here our group included someone who was hard of hearing and solely because of that, this restaurant was not the best choice (despite all the positives). The second time around (a younger group) we all got used to the noise level and coped fine.
Super brunch menu, great service!
Food was excellent, and there were several things I would like to go back and try. Good coffee. Tasteful gender neutral bathroom. It was a very loud hipster diner— not an intimate dining experience. A little pricey, but i am not a new yorker, so pretty much the whole weekend had me in sticker shock.
Always good food, drinks and service