Buffalo Dining Club
Evening ruined by rude waitress - sarcastic, slamming down water bottles because we had the audacity to ask for some more. Food was awesome as always but having been here many times before I was embarrassed to have recommended to my colleagues. Yes the food is good but there are many other places where you aren't made to feel like an inconvenience for being a customer. Will not be going back sadly.
The food was pretty good for the selection there was. Definitely have to try it once.
We tried three pasta dishes - the two on the menu plus a special of the day. All of them were excellent. All of the other dishes we tried were equally as great. Our server was fun and very attentive. The atmosphere was light and casual, and we were able to relax for a couple of hours and enjoy drinks.
The food is absolutely delicious, especially the spaghetti served from the cheese wheel. Definitely reccomend to anyone who loves pasta and cheese.
The kitchen is to be commended at this restaurant. It is the reason that patrons return time and again. The food is of outstanding quality, prepared and cooked to a high standard every single time. This consistency is relatively uncommon across Sydney's restaurants - particularly in Darlinghurst and is core quality of Buffalo Dining Club.
Interesting experience with good food! Nice little warm place
Great place to dine. A must try. Food was amazing and the staff where very friendly.
Great food and service. Tables are tiny, stools for sitting and not much on wine list under $60.
Delicious food, and good value. good serving size and relaxed atmosphere.
Wonderful pasta and great to see a small menu with everything on it done so well!! Will be back again.
A series of incident just affected the entire experience. Hence the reason why I would not recommend.
Food was great. Service was very attentive.
Music was not right. I’m a fan of 90’s grunge and the red hot chilli peppers but it seems incongruous for this kind of restaurant (or any kind of restaurant).
There was also a bottle of wine on the bill which we never ordered. I picked up the error and the apologetic waiter corrected it. Then indicated the tipping function on the eftpos machine.
Always a great experience!
DELICIOUS! The menu may be minimalistic but the food is definitely not. It is all about taste and beautiful ingredients at this restaurant and as for the homemade Chilli.....yum. The lovely lady who waited our table was excellent as well. We will definitely be returning as often as possible.
Regulars there. As usual, great food and service. Alway feels welcome.
One of my favourite restaurants in Sydney. Great good, vibe and always a good time. Better for small intimate dinners.
Music loud. Decor too industrial (cafe look)/ uncomfortable. Service average. All this in light of the above avg prices of course which raised my expectation for a nice Italien meal and decor.
Pasta were cold probably due to Cheese wheel which should have been replaced as kind of empty. Once warmed up, the pecorino came through nice with spaghetti. Nice sauce with gnocchi but gnocchi not a smooth as hoped for.
Hostess attitude was dismal, she seemed to be hating her job and customers! Extremely rude and not accommodating!
The humidity upstairs was horrific! Invest in a dehumidifier!
The food staff and music were everything I expected
Excellent. The food was delicious. Simple flavours, beautifully delivered. The service was really good, and coupled we a very relaxed vibe there are no complaints.
Amazing food, service, atmosphere and music .... perfect
The food was great, and generous. I found the decor a bit dated and needing a refresh. My only complaint would be it was very loud upstairs and we had 2 tables empty so of it was full upstairs it would be a challenge to hear anything.
Interestingly clean and yummy food.
Pasta was excellent!
The food and environment was ok. Overall not a bad experience but nothing to write home about.
Food was great and well priced, wine list was nice also. Great place for a date night.
So, so good. New family favourite!
Amazing food, fantastic customer service and such a friendly and welcoming team of people running the place!
Would recommend and would definitely go back! Thanks for making our Good Friday one to remember.
This restaurant has become our favourite date night place. The food is insane, wine is incredible - don't miss out on this great spot.
The food was outstanding but the service was not great. Paying the bill was not easy and they put more money on our bill than what we actually ordered.
Came of course for the cacio e pepe - lived up to the hype! But everything was delicious.
Been here about 10 times before. This time in particular was extremely loud in comparison. We kindly asked the server if she could turn the music down but she had to check with the manager? Unfortunately this meant nothing happened. That was a shame as there was only us 2 and maybe 2 other couples dining at the time. The service was a bit average and everything seemed just a tiny bit too difficult for her but she wasn't overtly rude. The food here is always amazing and the service is usually always spot on it's just this one instance which was an outlier.
Amazing food, outstanding wine, world class service as always!
Great food, but even more noteworthy was the fantastic service. Our waiter was really friendly and engaging. An almost customised experience.
Thanks to all the staff!
The Buffalo Club is lots of fun. the food is delicious and the staff are attentive. It's pretty loud though so not suitable for every occasion.
Amazing food and even better service! Must try the chilli sauce and a little of everything off the menu.
I took the cheese platter with 2 sides and when the waiter realised one of my sides was the wrong one, he bought me the correct one in a spare plate at no extra cost, apologising a lot.
The food was really great, one of the best I tried in Sydney. I definitely recommend it.
Awesome. I wouldn't change a thing about a night out here. The service is incredible, food amazing and great atmosphere. I'll be going back as soon as possible.
The food is great and reasonably priced.
I came with an idea that I can actually eat my pasta in the mozzarella roll. Call me a trashy tourist, but I was disappointed I did not get to enjoy a more cheesy experience. Yet excluding this wrong assumption both pastas we ordered were excellent.
Simple menu with limited options, but this is a good thing! Great pasta