This was excellent but not tonlght
I really like BLT Prime, and went there again for a quick solo dinner during a business trip. Super attentive service, great food, good wine, can't go wrong. Only reason why not 5* on the food is due to the fact that the wine reduction which came with my braised short ribs could certainly be a little more generous, it seems it was merely brushed on the ribs (and the reduction was excellent, so bring more of it!)
I've been to the restaurant in its previous incarnations and would say that BLT is a significant upgrade.
Steak restaurants are never inexpensive however the quality of the food and the professionalism of the service provides "value" when seeking this type of dining experience.
It was good, not great. When paying these prices it should be great. Also, watch your check. Full round of drinks on ours that we never had. Could easily have been missed in a large check.
The food was excellent. Starting with a warm, delicious popover. My rip eye steak was done perfectly, as was my baked potato. Service was very attentive and helpful. I highly recommend the restaurant!
Best service and food! Must try if you haven’t been yet!
Both entrees were very salty.
Very overpriced for the service, lack of ambience, food (almost inedible) and efforts to have diners order side dishes despite the high prices of the entrees.
It was great
Great neighborhood spot to grab a drink or enjoy a steak. Will be returning soon!
We have come here many times since it opened and thought the food was some of the best on the UES. Unfortunately, they had a tough summer with people being away and have cut back considerably. The chopped vegetable salad used to be great and made with fresh lettuces. Now it's made with tasteless iceberg! The salmon with zucchini has 1 piece of zucchini. Another obvious change. My gin martini tasted watered down. I'm not sure if we'll return. The prices are the same, but they seem to be cutting back which will certainly drive loyal customers away.
Service was very good, Popover amazing! But this is a Steak House . The Steak was fair . Had the porterhouse. Strip side was full of senew and really not very good. When you go for prime steak you want to be impressed and this meat was not . Brussel sprouts brunt . Everything was really good except the steak which is the problem.
Every time I come here I leave more and more impressed. The service is what keeps me coming back - and the food and drinks are great too.
I regularly went to the east 20s location and it’s the same great quality as always.
Great as usual. Highly recommended.
Great food and great service!!!!
Restaurant is beautiful, popovers are my favorite and the filet mignon was cooked perfectly and was moist and juicy and delicious.
Delighted to have taken friends from Toronto and DC who were blown away!! EXCELLENT!
Love BLT Prime. Always a great meal and experience. Thanks
The dining experience was just exactly what an upscale New York City restaurant should be. We will make it one of our favorite places to go.
Excellent steaks, friendly and attentive service, but VERY expensive. $55.00 for a 10 Oz NY Strip is a too much. Should be a $45.00 price at the most. Over all I will go back.
Every time we eat there it is consistently very good! Great food and wonderful staff!
Best popovers EVER. Bone-in ribeye medium rare was perfectly cooked and extremely flavorful. Nice wine by the glass choices, though overpriced. I’d place it in the top 5-10% of NYC steakhouses. The new location on Lex in UES is magnificent.
We went to BLTPrime to celebrate a friend’s birthday. The experience was wonderful in every way. The service was extraordinary and attentive. The filet mignon was delicious as was the branzino. Desserts did not disappoint... yummy!!
Would definitely return.
Great food, service and generous drinks!
Wonderful addition to the neighborhood
Best steakhouse on the UES
Service a bit sluggish
Impeccable service, delicious food in a lovely place. The popovers are fabulous and HUGE! Steaks, salmon and brussel sprouts were all yummy.
It was very nice
I have visited all of the BLT properties and this is just as fantastic as the others. my husband told me not to come home unless I had a steak for him and it did not disappoint. We eat steak all over town and this is one of the best.. Also our waiter and manager were professional, personable and fantastic.
Overall dinner was very good. Service was a little slow to start but improved as the night went on
We had a delicious meal and evening at BLT Prime. The space is welcoming and comfortable.
Friend’s birthday...our server was great and made the birthday dinner a great one
The waitress was visibly disappointed when we said we weren’t drinking and then treated us less than adequately as a result. It was a summer Saturday and the restaurant had many empty tables.
We welcome the BLT group to the neighborhood. They have a good formula and consistent product.
This was our second time at this location. (First time in late June was better.) This time the service was uneven. Before we had even received the drinks we ordered, the server asked us if we were ready to order.....Having finished dinner, we sat with dirty dishes for a while before having to ask the server to have them cleared. Food was good. We will try it again and hope for better service next time.
I was underwhelmed w/the food & overwhelmed w/the price. I’m not in a hurry to return.
Delicious food, above and beyond service, lovely ambiance. This restaurant is really needed on the Upper East Side, and I hope it does very well.
This is a new location for me as BLT on 57th is closed for renovations. The location is beautiful. Service and food are great as always.