Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC
Table of 9, had a reservation at 8 and was seated by 8:20 so that’s perfectly fine. We stayed their for 3 plus hours eating and drinking and having a great time. I love Carmine’s and this location is the best. I go every time I am in NY which seems to be 2-3 times a year now.
Ambiance, Food and Service were Excellent. They were very helpful with my reservation and my celebration.
Sloppy, unprofessional service. Noisy. Waiter didn’t confirm order so we were essentially forced to eat a dish we didn’t really want - and it was bad.
Also, waiter forgot our wine order. Other dish was also well below average. Food bland and very unimpressive.
Impeccable service, absolutely delicious and enough food to feed a small army. Always a delight while in NYC!
Great birthday treat. Large portions and very good service
Our waitress was really sweet and attentive and genuinely cared. She recommended the wings which were great!
The noise level was overwhelming ,almost to the point of eliminating conversation. Food was good and portions more than generous. My recommendation to friends would be to go at off hours because of the noise.
Fantastic food and service. Can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. Family style always fun. Highly recommend
unbelievably fast service, and the most amazing cocktails
Antonio is the best waiter!!! accommodating, knowledgeable and very charming.... he made the best recommendations and we all enjoyed it.
Carmine’s has a reputation that is hard to live up too
It’s good but not great
Good for groups
Only thing we didn’t like was how we brought our own cake and was charged a $3 fee for every person who wanted a slice. Service was kind of all over the place, but it was 12 of us. Food was great
Delicious food! Great service! Food is a little pricey even for family portions seeing as none of the entree dishes come with sides. Worth it if you’re willing to spend a little extra.
Great experience with the biggest meals ever, clearly meant for sharing. Food was amazing, service was awesome, great atmosphere. Loved Carmine’s and will be back again!
Great atmosphere, excellent food. it makes you feel comfortable from the first minute you get it. Furthermore, if you are lucky enough to be served by Charly, your experience will be even better!
It was as amazing as I had hoped it would be taking my friend there on her first trip to NYC! Thank you for making it so much fun!
service was awesome. i had an issue sending the payment. i tried to email it but Ms Corinne thought i didnt send it and i sent it twice. i didn"t receive the finial contract and my understanding was the 2 4yr olds were free
Isabell our server was excellent
Excelent service. We ate spaghettis with meat, very tasteble. We were three and ate a lot. Well -cooked " al dente". For desert we had tiramisú, one can't missed it. Ot was too much food, so we took home the tiramisú it was left. Prices weren't too high
Friendly staff with excellent food leaving an overall great atmosphere
The food was amazing! The server was hospitable and knowledgeable about the food. Celebrated my daughters 15th birthday there. Now my mom wants to have it there too!!!! All my guest had a great time.
What a wonderful place to visit with Family and Friends. My favorite restaurant when I'm in NYC
We are a large party of ７．The hostess didn't want us to seat the table until all show-up. We are not so happy about it since early ones came 7:45 and the last one was coming 8:15 PM. (our uncle is always late and he let us to order the food anyway. We could finish the dinner way earlier.) At least let us sit and drink the time we reserve will make us happier. We had two bottles of wine and two appetizers two pasta dishes and a main dish. The Wednesday special of Veal was fantastic as our weiter Chris told us.
The food was superb, as usual. Our waiter, Omar “from Queens”, was great. His friendly, attentive and timely service demonstrates what excellent customer service should be. This restaurant is a family favorite and we will definitely be coming back.
We had a wonderful family dinner, and will definitely go back to Carmine’s for our next get-together!
Carmines is fabulous! From the moment they greet you to the waiter taking the order, it is a most positive experience! And, the food at Carmine's has no comparison, cooked to perfection - this is Italian food at it's best!
And the service is just wonderful! The waiter and General Manager always asking how everything was.
I highly recommend Carmine's to everyone! Enjoy the experience and great food at Carmine's!
Lots of fun. Italian American like they made years ago. Professional hard working staff.
Great experience, waiter (Chris) was very knowledgeable and friendly. He actually suggested our dinner, it was a great suggestion. Will go again! Only thing that needs improvement is..... A little cozier seating. My date and I were on our second date 😊
Great service and food was good. No complaints here the staff here is excellent and my wife loves the Titanic!
Reliable Italian restaurant, excellent for groups and families. The Amaretto sidecars were delicious but needed to be colder. The salmon was nicely cooked and the chicken parm was nicely seasoned, the garlic bread was delicious.
This is Carmine’s is the best one in the city.
Great service however need more food options especially dessert choice and a better way to celebrate birthdays i was not to happy about it but overall great time
Carmine’s exceeded our expectations! Food was wonderful and service was excellent.
Great experience! Food was good, service was good, good environment and quick Serivce!
Wonderful. Charlie our waiter was excellent and took care of us! Will definitely be back!
Great restaurant, very good food, excellent service. Didn’t rate it 5 stars ONLY because of the family-size servings, which makes it difficult for a party of two to explore more than one food option, try an appetizer, etc. would be nice if smaller portions were available. Otherwise, we loved the experience and will go back again.