Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC
Excellent food! We had a great time!!! Food was fresh and we enjoyed the environment!!
First time to see the rocketts with the grand kids
The service was good. The food was amazing! We will definitely come back with a larger party so we can try even more of the dishes!
It was my birthday celebration.
I made a reservation for 5 at 9:30 pm. I was not greeted when I first came in, and had to wait for the hostess to look up and acknowledge my existence. We showed up 10 minutes early and I was told someone would come over to me to take my group to our seat. We waited 30 minutes past our reservation time to get seated as their were some tables open. I told the host to push 2 of the tables together, but she replied with an attitude saying “then where are we suppose to put our 2 tops?” May I remind you we made reservations for a reason. After waiting another 10 minutes they finally sat us at the table I asked them to push together for us. Overall the food was amazing and my servers were great at accommodating us!
Food Salt intake was too heavy and made it hard for me to eat my meal.
The only reason we didn’t get 5 stars is really because the service was very very slow and it took forever for our server to get to us, for drinks, for ordering, etc. probably because he had too many tables.
The reception is the worst part of our experience.
We love this restaurant
This is the second time we have been there within 10 months.
We travel from Philadelphia and make a weekend trip out of it.
We always make a reservation to Carmine’s. Can’t miss it.
Although OpenTable offers the option to chose what type of occasion brings us to Carmine’s, the restaurant never acknowledges it.
Both times we have been there we have specified it’s for our anniversary or birthday and it doesn’t get recognized like at other restaurants where they do acknowledge it.
However, food ambiance and service is great.
Anything you order is going to be delicious
Great portions and service! The food was very flavorful and filling.
A New York icon that's ranks high on the fun spot list. Always great. Make a reservation for Saturday and order the prime rib. Can't miss.
Great service, food and ambiance. Reasonably priced for NYC too!
Really great food for a reasonable price. Portion size is perfect for families. Great and friendly service. A little noisy but not too bad.
As always... the food and service are always consistent!! We love coming here!!!
Excellent excellent excellent food!!!!! Would highly highly recommend this place and I am a picky Italian!
Carmine’s is always a good time, with great food, if you don’t mind braving the midtown crowds and insanity, but maybe that’s part of the fun... Be ready for hordes of tourists and huge portions of delicious food!
Had a great time. Only turn off was we didn't get our bread once we sat down and when we did it was cold
We were celebrating my wife's birthday, and they took into account my request for surprising her with a cheese cake and a song. The food was great, I would definitely come back here a second time.
The food was amazing and the Sangria was the best I ever had.
Anniversary. One of our FAV places in NYC...we come back every time we are in town! ❤️
We came over from London ,and that was our first sit down meal and we was very please, we was recommended and was not disappointed. Staff was friendly and accommodating and the food was superb!
Had a reservation d a broadway show to make. Took 40 minutes to be seated. Not worth that.
We had to get to a broadway show. They were very busy but got us in. Good and service were excellent. We will definitely be back.
Our party of 6 wisely ordered appropieately as this was our 2nd visit and of course the large portions served us all. We all each would have liked a menu. Only 2 menu were given and we were told sometimes only one menu is given per table.
I was worried about eating in a Times Square establishment as there is a reputation of less than good quality. His was not that. The downstairs was a bit loud but our table was upstairs and quieter. The food was really good (chicken all’s Roma) and plentiful. Too much for a table of two so we had leftovers to share with the less fortunate. I would highly recommend this restaurant
Always amazing service and food! Few restaurants are able do this.
Food and drink very good and worth the money and time.
Wait staff were extremely friendly and helpful during our experience.
It was definitely worth it!!!
Food & service was OUTSTANDING. Tyler, our server was wonderful. 1st time there and can’t wait to go back & try other dishes. Our 1st visit included Caesar salad, spaghetti and meatballs and for dessert we indulged in the “tugboat”. I have never had a better meatball, incredible. Everything was delicious and my son & I enjoyed ourselves immensely. Thanks Carmine’s. Hope to visit again soon.
Fridays special chicken meal was excellent.
Food and service were excellent. Great selection.
I love the food at Carmine's! It's noisy and fun and you share everything because most portions feed 5 people. They also have gluten free choices! Chicken scarpariello and gluten free penne vodka with house salad is the best.
Fantastic! Food is delicious and service was also great!
Best italian place in Manhattan. Just love it. I have brought many friends in the past months, and they are grateful with the selection.
Awesome service, amazing food as always
Awesome food and service, best part of our trip so far
I brought my relatives from Italy to Carmine's for dinner. My cousin is a chef in Naples and he commented that the food was wonderful. In fact everyone in my party was very pleased with the food and service. Our waiter Edwin was very helpful to us when we were ordering our dinner. I definitely will be going back to Carmine's.
Friendly staff, HUGE portions and delicious food. My second visit to the restaurant and will definitely go again when I am in NYC next. So much to choose from the menu too and great drinks menu!